---
title: "Implied consent laws: what they are and what refusal costs"
url: "https://lawconsensus.com/dui/implied-consent/"
type: guide
author: Dana Whitlock
published: 2026-11-12
updated: 2026-11-12
last_checked: 2026-11-12
---

# Implied consent laws: what they are and what refusal costs

Implied consent means that by driving you agree to a chemical test if you are arrested for DUI. Refusing usually costs you your license through a separate administrative case, and the Supreme Court allows states to make refusing a breath test a crime but not a warrantless blood test.

## In short

- All 50 states have implied consent laws, as the Supreme Court recorded in Birchfield (2016).
- License suspension or revocation is the standard consequence of refusal. California's first-refusal suspension is one year (Vehicle Code § 23612).
- States may criminalize refusing a breath test after arrest but not a warrantless blood test (Birchfield, June 23, 2016).
- Refusal is generally admissible as evidence of likely intoxication, according to Birchfield.
- In California you have no right to a lawyer before deciding whether to take the test.

## What implied consent means

When you get a driver's license, the law treats you as having agreed to chemical testing if you are arrested on suspicion of DUI. The Supreme Court wrote in Birchfield v. North Dakota (June 23, 2016) that "all 50 States have adopted implied consent laws," quoting Missouri v. McNeely (2013). New York passed the first such law in 1953, according to the opinion.

Birchfield says the laws were meant to help secure drivers' cooperation with testing. Penalties for refusing give drivers a reason to agree.

## Two kinds of consequence

### Administrative: your license

Birchfield says suspension or revocation of the driver's license "remains the standard legal consequence of refusal." That penalty comes from the motor vehicle agency, not the criminal court, and it applies whether or not you are convicted.

California is a worked example. The officer must tell you that refusing a required test brings a one-year suspension, a two-year revocation if you have a prior DUI-type offense or suspension within 10 years, or a three-year revocation with two or more (Vehicle Code § 23612(a)(1)(D)). It also warns of a fine and mandatory jail on conviction. See [California's page on refusing a test](https://lawconsensus.com/dui/california/refusing-a-test/).

The refusal case is separate from the criminal case. You can ask for a hearing, and the deadline is short: in California, a request made within 10 days of receiving the notice gets you a hearing before the suspension takes effect (Vehicle Code § 13558(b)). See [the license hearing](https://lawconsensus.com/dui/license-hearing/).

### Criminal: a new charge for refusing

Some states make the refusal itself a crime, often with a higher penalty if the refusal follows a prior. Birchfield names North Dakota and Minnesota as states that did so in 2016. The current number of such states changes, so check your state's statute. 


## What Birchfield allows states to criminalize

Birchfield decided three related cases on June 23, 2016.

| Test refused | Can a state make refusing a crime? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Breath test after a lawful DUI arrest | Yes | A breath test is a permitted search incident to arrest, so the driver had no right to refuse |
| Warrantless blood test | No | Blood tests are more intrusive and are not covered by search-incident-to-arrest or by implied consent alone |

The Court wrote that it is "one thing" to approve implied consent laws with civil penalties and evidentiary consequences, "but quite another" to demand an intrusive blood test and criminally punish refusal. Police can still get a warrant, and McNeely and Mitchell address when a blood draw without one is allowed. See [blood and urine tests](https://lawconsensus.com/dui/blood-and-urine-tests/).

Birchfield also sent one case back because a driver agreed to a blood test after being told refusal was a crime, which was partly wrong under the new ruling.

## How refusal is used in court

Birchfield says evidence of refusal is admitted as evidence of likely intoxication in a DUI prosecution. California's advisory says the refusal "may be used against him or her in a court of law" (Vehicle Code § 23612(a)(4)). California also requires the officer to tell you that you have no right to an attorney before deciding or during the test.

Refusing leaves the prosecution without a BAC number, so its case rests on the driving, field tests and officer observations. See [defenses](https://lawconsensus.com/dui/defenses/). Whether and how refusal may be argued to a jury, and what the officer must have told you first, differs by state.


## Unconscious drivers

A driver who cannot refuse is treated as not having withdrawn consent in California (Vehicle Code § 23612(a)(5)). Under Mitchell v. Wisconsin (2019), a warrantless blood draw of an unconscious driver is generally allowed.

## What to do next

1. If you were asked to test, write down exactly what you were told and what you chose, with times.
2. Find the license-suspension notice you were handed. It shows your hearing deadline. See [what to do after an arrest](https://lawconsensus.com/dui/arrested-what-now/).
3. Request the hearing before the deadline and learn the process.
4. Read how a suspension works and how you get a license back in [license suspension and reinstatement](https://lawconsensus.com/dui/license-suspension-and-reinstatement/).

## Questions people ask

### Do I have the right to talk to a lawyer before taking the test?

Not in California. The officer must tell you that you have no right to have an attorney present before deciding to take a test or during it, and that a refusal may be used against you (Vehicle Code § 23612(a)(4)). Other states have their own rules.

### Can the refusal be used against me at trial?

Birchfield describes the usual practice: evidence of refusal is admitted as evidence of likely intoxication in a drunk-driving prosecution. California's advisory says the same (Vehicle Code § 23612(a)(4)).

### Can police take my blood if I refuse?

Only with a warrant or an emergency exception, under Missouri v. McNeely and Mitchell v. Wisconsin. Under Birchfield a state cannot punish you criminally for refusing a warrantless blood draw.

### Do I lose my license even if I am found not guilty of DUI?

Possibly. The license penalty for refusal is a separate administrative case. In California, a DMV hearing finding does not control the criminal case and does not stop the same facts from being argued there (Vehicle Code § 13558(g)).

## Sources

- [Birchfield v. North Dakota, 579 U.S. 438 (2016) (U.S. Reports, GPO)](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-579/pdf/USREPORTS-579-438.pdf)
- [Missouri v. McNeely, 569 U.S. 141 (2013) (U.S. Reports, GPO)](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-569/pdf/USREPORTS-569-141.pdf)
- [Mitchell v. Wisconsin (2019) (Supreme Court of the United States)](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/18pdf/18-6210_2co3.pdf)
- [California Vehicle Code § 23612 (California Legislative Information)](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=VEH&sectionNum=23612)
- [California Vehicle Code § 13558 (California Legislative Information)](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=VEH&sectionNum=13558)

_General information, sources checked Nov 12, 2026. Not legal advice._
