---
title: "Starting and running a small business: the legal side"
url: "https://lawconsensus.com/business/"
type: hub
practice_area: Business
author: Tobias Lindgren
published: 2026-11-12
last_checked: 2026-11-12
---

# Starting and running a small business: the legal side

A business has two legal identities that people confuse. The entity is created under state law and decides who is liable. The tax treatment is chosen with the IRS and decides how profit is taxed. An LLC can be taxed four different ways.

## In short

- Forming an LLC or corporation separates business debts from your personal assets. It works only if you keep the two apart in practice.
- Entity type and tax status are separate choices. “S corporation” is a tax election, not a kind of company.
- The state creates the company. The IRS issues its tax number. Your city or county licenses what it does.
- Most business disputes turn on what was written down. An agreement between owners matters more than any other document.

## Federal numbers every owner meets

| Figure | What it is | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 21% flat rate | of federal income tax on a C corporation’s profit. Shareholders are taxed again on dividends. | 26 U.S.C. § 11(b) |
| 100 shareholders | at most for a company taxed as an S corporation, with one class of stock and no foreign shareholders. | 26 U.S.C. § 1361(b)(1) |
| 2½ months | into the tax year is the deadline to elect S corporation status for that year, on Form 2553. | 26 U.S.C. § 1362(b) |
| 3 business days | after a new employee starts work to complete Form I-9, verifying identity and the right to work. | 8 C.F.R. § 274a.2(b)(1)(ii) |

## A business’s legal life, in order

### 1. Choosing a structure

The first decision, and the one that shapes liability and tax.

- **Doing nothing is a choice.** Start trading alone and you are a sole proprietor. Start with someone else and you are a general partnership. In both, owners are personally liable for business debts.
- **Liability protection.** An LLC or corporation is a separate legal person. Its debts are its own, so creditors generally cannot reach an owner’s home or savings.
- **Where the protection ends.** You remain liable for your own wrongdoing, for debts you personally guarantee, and if you treat the company’s money as your own.
- **Tax follows a separate choice.** An LLC is taxed as a sole proprietorship or partnership by default and can elect to be taxed as an S or C corporation.

### 2. Forming the company

Paperwork with the state, then with your co-owners.

- **The formation filing.** Articles of organization for an LLC, articles of incorporation for a corporation, filed with the secretary of state for a fee.
- **Which state.** For most small businesses, the state where you operate. Forming elsewhere usually means registering and paying fees in both.
- **A registered agent.** Every company must name a person or service with a street address in the state to receive lawsuits and official mail.
- **The owners’ agreement.** An operating agreement or bylaws and a shareholder agreement: who owns what, who decides, and what happens when someone leaves. Without one, state default rules apply.

### 3. Tax numbers and licenses

Three levels of government, three sets of registrations.

- **EIN.** An Employer Identification Number from the IRS, free, online. Needed to open a business bank account, hire, or file most business returns.
- **State tax accounts.** Sales tax if you sell taxable goods or services, and payroll and unemployment accounts once you hire.
- **Licenses and permits.** A general business license from the city or county in many places, plus professional or industry licenses for regulated work.
- **A trade name.** Operating under a name other than the legal one usually requires a “doing business as” registration.

### 4. Contracts and day-to-day

Where most legal trouble starts, and can be prevented.

- **Put it in writing.** Scope, price, payment terms, deadlines, and what happens if either side fails. Sales of goods of $500 or more generally need a writing to be enforced.
- **Sign as the company.** Sign with the company’s name and your title. Signing in your own name can make you personally liable.
- **Keep the company separate.** Its own bank account, its own records, no personal bills paid from it. This is what keeps liability protection intact.
- **Commercial leases.** Few of the protections residential tenants have apply. Personal guarantees, repair duties and renewal terms are all negotiable, before signing.

### 5. Hiring

The point at which a business takes on the most new obligations.

- **Employee or contractor.** The law decides by the real relationship, mainly how much control you have, not by the label in your agreement. Getting it wrong means back taxes and penalties.
- **On every hire.** Form I-9 to verify the right to work, Form W-4 for withholding, and a new-hire report to your state.
- **Payroll taxes.** You withhold income tax and the employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare, pay the employer’s share, and deposit them on a schedule. Owners can be personally liable for unpaid payroll taxes.
- **Workplace rules.** Minimum wage, overtime, workers’ compensation insurance, and anti-discrimination law, with thresholds that depend on headcount.

### 6. Protecting what you build

Names, ideas and risk.

- **Your name.** Registering a company name with the state does not give trademark rights. Search existing trademarks before you invest in a brand, and consider federal registration.
- **Who owns the work.** Work made by employees in their job belongs to the business. Work made by contractors usually belongs to them unless a signed agreement says otherwise.
- **Confidential information.** Trade secrets are protected only if you take reasonable steps to keep them secret, such as confidentiality agreements and access limits.
- **Insurance.** General liability, professional liability, and workers’ compensation where required. Liability protection and insurance cover different risks.

### 7. Disputes, selling and closing

How things end, well or badly.

- **Disputes between owners.** The owners’ agreement decides almost everything: buyout terms, deadlock, valuation. Without one, the remedy is often a lawsuit to dissolve the company.
- **Getting paid.** A demand letter, then small claims court for smaller debts, where lawyers are often unnecessary.
- **Selling.** A sale of assets and a sale of the company itself have different tax and liability results for both sides.
- **Closing properly.** File dissolution papers with the state, file final tax returns, and close tax accounts. A company left to lapse keeps accruing fees and filings.

## Compare the common structures

Four structures cover nearly every small business. Pick one to see how it is formed, who is liable, and how it is taxed.

### Sole proprietorship

You and the business are legally the same person. This is the default when one person starts trading.

- **How it is formed:** No filing creates it. You may still need a business license and a trade-name registration.
- **Personal liability:** Unlimited. Business debts and lawsuits can reach your personal assets.
- **Federal income tax:** Profit is reported on Schedule C of your own return. You pay self-employment tax on it.
- **Owners:** One.
- **Upkeep:** The least. No separate return, no annual report.

### LLC

A separate legal entity with flexible tax treatment. The most common choice for a new small business.

- **How it is formed:** Articles of organization filed with the state, plus an operating agreement among the members.
- **Personal liability:** Limited to what you put in, if you keep the company’s affairs separate from your own.
- **Federal income tax:** By default, like a sole proprietorship with one member or a partnership with several. It can elect to be taxed as an S or C corporation.
- **Owners:** One or more members, of any kind, with no upper limit.
- **Upkeep:** An annual or biennial report and fee in most states. Some states charge an annual franchise tax.

### S corporation

Not a kind of company. It is a tax status that an eligible corporation or LLC elects with the IRS.

- **How it is formed:** Form the corporation or LLC with the state, then file Form 2553 with the IRS.
- **Personal liability:** Limited, from the underlying corporation or LLC.
- **Federal income tax:** Profit passes through to owners’ returns with no corporate tax. Owners who work in the business must be paid a reasonable salary through payroll.
- **Owners:** No more than 100, all U.S. citizens or residents or certain trusts and estates, with one class of stock.
- **Upkeep:** Payroll for owner-employees, a separate return on Form 1120-S, and the state’s corporate or LLC formalities.

### C corporation

The standard corporation. The usual choice for a company that plans to raise outside investment.

- **How it is formed:** Articles of incorporation filed with the state, bylaws, a board of directors, and issued shares.
- **Personal liability:** Limited to what shareholders invest.
- **Federal income tax:** The corporation pays 21 percent on its profit. Shareholders pay tax again on dividends.
- **Owners:** Any number and kind of shareholder, with multiple classes of stock allowed.
- **Upkeep:** The most: board and shareholder meetings, minutes, a corporate return on Form 1120, and annual state filings.

_A general comparison under federal tax law. State taxes and fees differ, and the right structure depends on your income, co-owners and plans. General information, not legal or tax advice._

## What changes at the state line

Companies are created under state law, and each state sets its own price and paperwork. Tax at the federal level is the same everywhere.

- **Formation and annual fees:** Filing fees, annual reports, and franchise taxes that range from nothing to hundreds of dollars a year.
- **LLC rules:** Whether an operating agreement is required, publication requirements, and default rules among members.
- **State income and sales tax:** Whether the state taxes business income, how it treats S corporations, and what sales are taxed.
- **Licenses:** Which trades and professions need a state license, and what cities add.
- **Non-compete agreements:** Enforceable in some states, restricted or void in others.
- **Small claims limits:** How large a debt you can pursue without a full lawsuit, and whether a company can appear without a lawyer.

## What business lawyers handle

- **Starting:** Choosing and forming an entity, Operating and shareholder agreements, Buying an existing business, Franchise agreements
- **Running:** Customer and supplier contracts, Commercial leases, Hiring and contractor agreements, Licenses and compliance
- **Protecting:** Trademarks, Copyright and work-for-hire, Trade secrets and confidentiality, Non-compete agreements
- **Disputes and exits:** Breach of contract, Partner and shareholder disputes, Collecting unpaid invoices, Selling or dissolving a business, Succession planning

## Two identities

Every business has a legal form and a tax treatment, and they are decided in different places. The legal form, sole proprietorship, partnership, LLC or corporation, is a matter of state law. It decides who owns the business, who can bind it, and above all who is liable for its debts. The tax treatment is a matter of federal law, chosen with the IRS, and decides how profit reaches the owners and at what cost.

The two overlap less than people expect. An LLC with one owner is ignored for federal income tax unless it elects otherwise. The same LLC can elect to be taxed as an S corporation or a C corporation without changing anything about its legal form. "S corporation" describes only the tax election (26 U.S.C. § 1361), which is why a company can be both an LLC and an S corporation.

## What limited liability really covers

An LLC or corporation puts a wall between the business's obligations and the owner's personal assets. The wall has gaps. You are always liable for harm you personally cause. Lenders and landlords routinely ask small-business owners for personal guarantees, which bypass the wall by contract. And a court can disregard the company altogether if the owner has treated it as a personal wallet, with mixed funds, no records and too little capital. Keeping a separate bank account and signing contracts in the company's name are what keep the protection real.

## The agreement between owners

When a business has more than one owner, the most important document is the agreement among them: who contributes what, how decisions are made, how profit is shared, and what happens when an owner wants out, dies, divorces or stops working. If you do not write one, your state's default rules apply, and they are rarely what the owners would have chosen.

## Becoming an employer

Hiring the first employee adds more legal duties than any other step: verifying the right to work, withholding and depositing payroll taxes, carrying workers' compensation insurance, and following wage and anti-discrimination laws. Treating workers as independent contractors does not avoid these duties if the working relationship is really employment, and misclassification is one of the most common and costly mistakes a small business makes.

## Ownership reporting

The federal Corporate Transparency Act created a requirement to report a company's owners to the Treasury Department. In March 2025 the Treasury removed that requirement for companies formed in the United States. Check the current position on the FinCEN website before relying on either rule.

## Questions people ask

### Do I need an LLC to start a business?

No. You can operate as a sole proprietor with no filing. An LLC is worth forming when the business could create debts or liability you would not want to pay personally, or when you have co-owners.

### What is the difference between an LLC and an S corporation?

An LLC is a legal entity created under state law. An S corporation is a federal tax status. An LLC can elect S corporation tax treatment if it meets the eligibility rules, so a business can be both.

### Should I form my company in Delaware?

For most small businesses, no. If you operate in another state you must still register and pay fees there. Delaware mainly suits companies planning to raise venture capital.

### Does an LLC protect my personal assets?

From the business’s debts, generally yes. Not from your own wrongdoing, debts you personally guaranteed, unpaid payroll taxes, or cases where you did not keep the company’s finances separate from your own.

### Do I need an EIN?

Yes if the business has employees, is a corporation or partnership, or is a multi-member LLC. A sole proprietor without employees can use a Social Security number, though banks often ask for an EIN.

### Is a handshake deal enforceable?

Often, but proving its terms is hard, and some contracts must be in writing to be enforced, including sales of goods of $500 or more and agreements that cannot be completed within a year.

## Related

- [Find a business lawyer](https://lawconsensus.com/practice-areas/business/)
- [Employment](https://lawconsensus.com/employment/): The rules you take on with your first hire, seen from the worker’s side.
- [Estate planning](https://lawconsensus.com/estate-planning/): What happens to the business if an owner dies or cannot work.
- [Landlord-tenant](https://lawconsensus.com/landlord-tenant/): Leases, though commercial tenants have far fewer protections.

## Sources

- [U.S. Small Business Administration, choose a business structure (sba.gov)](https://www.sba.gov/business-guide/launch-your-business/choose-business-structure)
- [IRS, business structures (irs.gov)](https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/business-structures)
- [26 U.S.C. § 11, tax imposed on corporations (govinfo.gov)](https://www.govinfo.gov/link/uscode/26/11?type=usc&year=mostrecent&link-type=html)
- [26 U.S.C. § 1361, S corporation defined (govinfo.gov)](https://www.govinfo.gov/link/uscode/26/1361?type=usc&year=mostrecent&link-type=html)
- [26 U.S.C. § 1362, S corporation election (govinfo.gov)](https://www.govinfo.gov/link/uscode/26/1362?type=usc&year=mostrecent&link-type=html)
- [26 C.F.R. § 301.7701-3, classification of business entities (ecfr.gov)](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-26/section-301.7701-3)
- [IRS, get an employer identification number (irs.gov)](https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/get-an-employer-identification-number)
- [IRS, independent contractor or employee? (irs.gov)](https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/independent-contractor-self-employed-or-employee)
- [26 U.S.C. § 6672, personal liability for unpaid withheld taxes (govinfo.gov)](https://www.govinfo.gov/link/uscode/26/6672?type=usc&year=mostrecent&link-type=html)
- [USCIS, Form I-9 employment eligibility verification (uscis.gov)](https://www.uscis.gov/i-9)
- [U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, trademark basics (uspto.gov)](https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/basics)
- [17 U.S.C. § 101, definition of a work made for hire (govinfo.gov)](https://www.govinfo.gov/link/uscode/17/101?type=usc&year=mostrecent&link-type=html)
- [FinCEN, beneficial ownership information reporting (fincen.gov)](https://www.fincen.gov/boi)

_General information, sources checked Nov 12, 2026. Not legal advice._
